The Subscriber Queries That Cost the Most

Every subscriptions team knows the feeling. The phone rings, and it's the same question you answered yesterday, and the day before, from someone different.

Customer service is usually measured by how quickly the phone gets answered. That matters. But the bigger saving comes from asking why people are ringing at all. Most subscriber queries aren't really customer service problems. They're data, process or wording problems that turn up on the phone.

What makes a query expensive

A query costs more than the few minutes it takes to answer. The expensive ones share a few traits:

  • They come back. If the fix doesn't stick, the same reader rings again next issue, usually less patient.
  • They need more than one person. Anything that has to go to finance, the editor or the mailing house takes days, not minutes.
  • They cost money directly. Replacement copies, postage, refunds and credit notes.
  • They lose the renewal. A reader who has had to chase you three times is not in a generous mood when the renewal notice arrives.

With that in mind, here are the usual suspects and what to do about each.

"My copy hasn't arrived"

This is the classic. The temptation is to send a replacement and move on, and for a one-off that's fine. The real cost is when it keeps happening to the same reader, or the same postcode, or the same company.

So record every missed copy against the reader's record, with the issue. Then look at them together once a month. A cluster at one address usually means a bad address, a building with a post room that loses things, or a reader who has left. A cluster across one issue points at the printer, the mailing house or the post. You can't spot either pattern if replacements are just sent from an email inbox.

Check the address before you send the replacement, too. If the first copy went to the wrong place, the second one will follow it. Our post on gone-aways goes into why returned copies deserve the same attention.

"I've moved" (and the reader who didn't tell you)

Address changes are cheap when the reader tells you in good time and the change goes straight onto the file. They get expensive when the change is noted somewhere other than the subscription record, or made after the mailing file for the next issue has already gone.

Two fixes help. Know your cut-off for each title, and tell readers what it is when they ask, so they know whether the next issue will reach the new address. And let readers update their own details online, if your system allows it. Every change a reader makes themselves is a call you don't take and a typing error you don't make.

In B2B, a lot of "moves" are job changes. The person has gone, and the copy keeps arriving for someone who doesn't want it. Treat that as a chance to ask who has replaced them, not just a cancellation.

"Why have I been charged this?"

Payment queries tend to be the slowest, because they usually need someone in finance. They come from a handful of causes: a price rise the reader didn't notice, an automatic renewal they forgot about, a direct debit collected on a date they didn't expect, or a company invoice without the purchase order number their accounts team needs.

Nearly all of those are fixed before the money is taken, not after. Say clearly, in the renewal notice, what will be charged and when. Put the purchase order number on company invoices when you have it, and ask for it when you don't. And if you take direct debits, remember the Direct Debit Guarantee requires advance notice of any change to the amount or date. A clear notice now is a lot cheaper than a refund later.

"I want to cancel"

Cancellations are queries you can't make go away, and you shouldn't try. Readers leave. What costs time is a cancellation process that only works by phone, or that needs a call back, or that leaves the reader unsure whether it has actually happened.

For consumer subscriptions that renew automatically, this is about to become a legal question as well as a service one. The new subscription rules are due to apply to contracts entered into from 1 January 2027, though the regulations still need Parliament's approval. The government's draft guidance says the intention is that exiting "should be as easy as signing up". If readers could sign up online, they must be able to end it online, and the guidance doesn't think an email address alone is enough. You then send an end of contract notice with the end date, within 24 hours if they ended it online. Retention offers are allowed, but they mustn't drag the process out.

That's a service win as well as a compliance one. A cancellation done properly the first time is one contact. A muddled one is three, plus a complaint.

Company-paid subscriptions are outside those rules. But a quick, clear cancellation is good service whoever pays. Our guide to the subscription rules covers what's required, and the free checklist turns it into tasks.

"I can't log in"

If you have a paid digital edition with a login, forgotten passwords will be a steady trickle of email. The fix is mostly self-service: a password reset that works without a human, and a clear message on the login page saying which email address to use.

The harder queries are the ones where the reader has paid but has no access, or has cancelled but still can. Both usually mean the digital platform keeps its own list of readers, separate from the subscription file. If access is switched on and off from the same record as the subscription, these mostly disappear. We wrote about that in digital editions and the subscriber file.

Make every query easier to answer

Whatever the query, a few habits cut the time it takes:

  1. One record per reader. If the person on the phone has to search three systems, every call takes three times as long.
  2. Log the contact on the record. Whoever picks up next can see what was promised last time, and the reader doesn't have to explain it all again.
  3. Count the reasons. A simple reason code on each contact (missing copy, address, payment, cancellation, access) is enough. Look at the counts monthly and fix the biggest one.
  4. Fix the wording, not just the reader. If one renewal letter generates a lot of calls, it's probably the letter. Rewrite it.
  5. Keep a short script for the common ones. Not to sound robotic, just so every reader gets the same, correct answer.

Where we fit in

Our subscription and circulation bureau answers readers in your name, logs what happened against their record, and passes complaints to you only when they need your decision. In Avio, our subscription platform for larger publishers, missed copies are recorded against the subscriber and replacement copies can be exported by date range. In Adeptis, our all-in-one platform for smaller publishers, each subscription shows its issues remaining, so "how many have I got left?" has a straight answer.

If your team spends more time on the phone than it would like, get in touch and we'll talk it through.

Rob Sherwood

Rob Sherwood is Managing Director of Adept Data Services. He has spent his career in subscriptions and circulation, at WDIS, Optima and CDS Global before founding Adept.

More about Rob at rob-sherwood.co.uk

Talk to people who know publishing

Tell us what you're trying to fix. You'll speak to someone who has run circulation and subscriptions for a living, not a sales script.